Loading…
Workshop · 28 July 2024 · 3 min read
At first glance, this law remains very vague and open to interpretation. The law is difficult to understand and states new concepts without providing their content or more details on the modalities of their implementation.
At first glance, this law remains very vague and open to interpretation. The law is difficult to understand and states new concepts without providing their content or more details on the modalities of their implementation.
It mainly aims to construct a commercial market, where "sustainable development projects" can offset their negative impacts on the environment and local communities by trading what the law calls "sustainable development credits."
The law does not provide additional information about the identity or function of these concessions: it could refer to all concessions involved in the exploitation of natural resources (forests, agriculture, mining, protected areas, etc.) as well as community lands. These "sustainable development concessions" generate "sustainable development credits," credits that are "generated by the creation, improvement, or maintenance of sustainable development assets related to a sustainable development activity."
Yet, this is an essential aspect because it is human beings who constitute the purpose of sustainable development. This omission is all the more incomprehensible given that regarding the participation of local populations, it is clear that this law should, among other things, help pave the way for the implementation of the Nagoya Protocol, to which Gabon is a party. But rather, we observe its obstruction to the application of the Nagoya Protocol.
In the end, this law emphasizes the affirmation of many principles, which is not useless, but misses the essential, notably the consideration of the rights of local communities and the involvement of civil society and the private sector. It is dangerous in that it introduces a new system of exchange credits, which will pave the way for a more "destructive" than "sustainable" development.
If these considerations are added to the observation of the land and economic insecurity of forest communities, the framework becomes increasingly concerning.
In this context, and due to failing governance, the passage of this national policy based on compensation to achieve sustainable development objectives is extremely insidious, as it once again excludes the participation of local and indigenous communities. This law indeed does not guarantee any protection for the rights of communities, and they will have no say regarding the administration of compensations that directly concern them. On the contrary, they are simply treated as commodities with potential compensations that can be traded by the government and private investors. It goes without saying that such an approach is completely incompatible with international human rights law, as well as with the basic legal principles of private property (all enshrined in the Gabonese constitutional block).
Such a system does not promote any form of sustainable development but will result in increased damage to the environment and communities. If this approach were to be perceived as a model by other governments in the region, the implications of this new law would be even more disastrous, beyond Gabon's borders.
Civil Society Organizations in general, and the Gabon My Land My Right Platform (GMTMD), remain available and open to participate in any consultation framework aimed at improving this law and particularly to contribute during the drafting of implementing texts. It is indeed essential that before the adoption of implementing texts, the contentious points be analyzed and discussed for their integration into an improved version of the said Law.